Skip to main content

Ethernet Common Mode Choke Placement: Cable Side or PHY Side of the Transformer?

VOOHU Technical Team ·Published ·Updated ·6 min read

An Ethernet common mode choke can sit on either side of the isolation transformer, and both arrangements are in use. On the cable side, it meets common-mode noise from the cable before that noise reaches the transformer; on the PHY (chip) side, it meets noise from the board first. PoE changes the picture: the power current enters through the cable-side center taps, so a two-winding choke on the cable side would carry that DC as common-mode current. In a PoE port, the choke must not let that DC bias its core. A common way is to place the choke on the chip side, as in the VOOHU PoE transformers below. Without PoE, follow the magnetics requirements of your PHY. VOOHU supplies both structures, and each part's datasheet schematic shows where its choke sits.

#Where should a common mode choke be placed in Ethernet magnetics?

Each channel of Ethernet magnetics has a chip side, wired to the PHY's MDI pins, and a cable side, wired to the RJ45. Each side of the transformer has a center tap: on the chip side it goes to whatever the PHY datasheet specifies, and on the cable side it carries the termination network and, in a PoE port, the power current. The choke is placed in series with the pair on one side or the other.

Ethernet magnetics with the common mode choke on the cable side versus the chip side, showing the PoE current path

Two structures: the choke between transformer and RJ45 (cable side), or between PHY and transformer (chip side). With PoE, the current from the cable passes through a cable-side choke but goes straight to the center tap when the choke is on the chip side. Generic two-winding choke shown; not a specific part. Schematic only.

#Ethernet CM choke: which side, and what changes?

QuestionChoke on the cable sideChoke on the chip (PHY) side
Which noise meets the choke before the transformer?Common-mode noise arriving from the cableCommon-mode noise from the PHY and the board
Does PoE current pass through the choke?Yes, if the port carries PoE: it flows through both windings on its way to the cable-side center tapNo: the cable-side center tap connects to the transformer directly
What sets the choice when there is no PoE?The magnetics requirements in your PHY datasheet or the PHY vendor's reference design
VOOHU example (datasheet schematic)SYT111Q066AA2A1D (RJ45 jack with integrated magnetics, no PoE rating)WHSG24Z01C0 and WHSG24702PG (PoE-rated discrete transformers)

#Why does PoE change where the common mode choke goes?

A common mode choke works because the two halves of a differential signal flow in opposite directions, so their magnetic flux cancels in the core, while common-mode current flows the same way in both windings and meets a high impedance. PoE current is delivered through the center taps and splits between the two wires of a pair, flowing the same way in both. To a choke in series with that pair, it is common-mode current, so its flux adds instead of cancelling and biases the core, which lowers the impedance the choke was chosen for.

Two VOOHU PoE-rated gigabit transformers show the chip-side structure in their datasheet schematics:

  • WHSG24Z01C0: the schematic is labelled Cable Side and Chip Side, and the choke is on the Chip Side. Each channel's choke has three windings, so TD+, TD− and the chip-side center tap TCT all pass through it, while the cable-side center tap MCT connects straight to the transformer. The datasheet states 1.5 A DC balance current per channel and 3.0 A per port.
  • WHSG24702PG: the choke (two windings) is on the side opposite the printed Cable Side, and the cable-side center tap connects straight to the transformer. The datasheet states PoE support of 60 W, 600 mA DC balance current per channel and 1200 mA for all channels.

The same reasoning applies to a choke added outside the magnetics. Small signal-line chokes such as the WHLC-2012A series, rated 300 mA max, belong on lines that carry no PoE current. In a PoE port, choose magnetics whose datasheet states a PoE current, and check where its choke sits.

#Without PoE, is the cable side or the PHY side better?

There is no single answer, so start from the PHY. PHY datasheets differ in how the chip-side center tap is connected: to a supply on some devices, only to a bypass capacitor on others. The magnetics section of the PHY datasheet, or the vendor's reference schematic, tells you which, and a transformer whose structure matches that reference is the safe starting point. Then check the choke's position on the transformer's own schematic rather than assuming it.

VOOHU's non-PoE SYT111Q066AA2A1D RJ45 jack with integrated magnetics, for example, has a coupling element drawn as a common mode choke on the cable side of each pair, while the PoE version SYT111Q334AB2A2DP057 has it on the PHY side.

#How do you tell which side the choke is on from a datasheet?

  1. 1.Look for printed side labels. Many schematics print Cable Side, Chip Side or PHY Side next to the pins. Trust those words over the pin names.
  2. 2.Do not rely on net names. Across VOOHU's own datasheets, the cable side is labelled MX / MCT on some parts and TD / TCT on another, so "MX means cable side" is not a safe rule.
  3. 3.Follow each center tap. See whether the cable-side center tap reaches the transformer directly or through the choke, and whether the chip-side center tap passes through the choke.
  4. 4.If neither side is labelled, ask. Our FAE team can confirm which side of a VOOHU part goes to the RJ45.

For the rest of the datasheet, see how to read an Ethernet transformer datasheet.

#Ethernet transformer common mode choke: VOOHU parts by structure

Gigabit parts whose datasheet schematics show the choke position:

PartTypeChoke position on the datasheet schematicSide labels printedPoE (from the datasheet)
WHSG24Z01C0Gigabit discrete LAN transformer, 24-pin SMDChip side; three windings per channel (TD+, TD−, TCT)Cable Side and Chip Side1.5 A DC balance current per channel; 3.0 A per port
WHSG24702PGGigabit discrete LAN transformer, 24-pin SMDSide opposite the printed Cable Side; two windingsCable Side only60 W; 600 mA DC balance current per channel, 1200 mA all channels
SYT111Q066AA2A1DGigabit RJ45 jack with integrated magneticsCable side; one element per pairPHY side and Cable sideNo PoE statement
SYT111Q334AB2A2DP057Gigabit PoE RJ45 jack with integrated magneticsPHY sidePHY side and Cable sidePoE version; cable-side center taps brought out to separate pins

For a PoE port on discrete magnetics, start from WHSG24Z01C0 for the higher per-channel current or WHSG24702PG, whose datasheet states 60 W PoE support. For a non-PoE port where board space is tight, a MagJack (RJ45 jack with integrated magnetics) such as SYT111Q066AA2A1D puts the magnetics, including a choke-style element on each pair, inside the connector. Compare more parts in the LAN transformer selector (filtered to 10/100/1000BASE-T), the gigabit LAN transformer range or the RJ45 jacks with integrated magnetics.

Where the choke sits is one decision; how the copper around the magnetics is laid out is another, covered in Ethernet magnetics PCB layout. For single-pair automotive links, see why 1000BASE-T1 uses a common mode choke.

WHSG24Z01C0
Transformer · LAN TransformerWHSG24Z01C0100/1000Base-T Single Ports 24PIN 4PPOE(up to 3000mA) LAN Transformer
SMDSingle Port241.27mm1500
SYT111Q334AB2A2DP057
I/O Connector · Network Connector (RJ45/RJ11)SYT111Q334AB2A2DP05790° side insertion 1*1 Tab Down POE 600mA G/Y 100/1000M DIP RJ45
RJ45 Connector90°1 x 1Down100/1000M600mA
SolutionEthernetInterface + magneticsView solution →

#FAQ

Should the common mode choke be on the cable side or the PHY side of an Ethernet transformer?

Either can work. In a PoE port, the PoE current must not bias the choke's core; a common way is to place a two-winding choke on the chip side, out of the path between the cable and the cable-side center taps. Without PoE, follow the magnetics requirements in your PHY datasheet, then confirm the position on the transformer's schematic.

Can I add a common mode choke on the RJ45 side of a PoE port?

A two-winding choke in series with the pairs there carries the PoE current as common-mode current, which biases its core (see why PoE changes the placement above). Its rated current is specified for the differential signal, so it does not cover this case. Small signal-line chokes such as the WHLC-2012A series (300 mA max) belong on lines without PoE current; for the port itself, use magnetics with a stated PoE current.

Does a LAN transformer already include a common mode choke?

Often, but check the schematic. All four VOOHU gigabit parts in the table above show a choke or choke-style element in each channel, on the side their schematic indicates. If the schematic shows only the transformer, any choke has to be placed on the board.

What is a common mode choke used for in Ethernet?

It passes the differential signal with little effect and presents a high impedance to common-mode current, reducing noise carried onto and off the cable. The transformer provides isolation and couples the signal; the choke adds common-mode suppression. See what is a common mode choke.

Have our FAE team check your magnetics

Send your PHY part number, whether the port carries PoE, and the magnetics part of your schematic through our sample and support form. Our FAE team can check which side the choke sits on in the transformer or RJ45 you are considering and suggest a VOOHU part with the matching structure. Samples are available for evaluation, and selected parts are free of charge. Our FAE team will be glad to confirm the options for your project. VOOHU supplies RJ45 and SFP connectors, LAN and PoE transformers and common mode chokes from Suzhou, China, to more than 1,500 customers.

Part of the series: Ethernet port magnetics from 10/100 to 10G

Previous: ground plane rules under Ethernet magnetics

Next: 10/100BASE-TX magnetics with ESD and surge protection

All articles on this topic

SAMPLES & SUPPORT

Need a quote, samples or selection support?

Part number WHSG24Z01C0 is filled in for you. Add the quantity and lead time and submit. Our FAE team will be glad to confirm the options for your project.

Before you order: samples, MOQ, lead time and import duties in our ordering guide →

REQUEST TYPE

Choose a Request Type and Fill in the Fields

Part number decided; you need samples, pricing, or lead time

Contact Details

Have attachments? Send datasheets, BOMs, or drawings to voohu@voohuele.com with your name and company, and our engineers will handle them together with this request.
  1. You see a confirmation right after submitting, and the request goes to our engineering queue

  2. Pricing and lead time within 1 business day; items without stock data are marked "To be confirmed"

  3. If information is missing, we list what we need first instead of closing the request

Update history

  1. Content updated
VOOHU Technical TeamVOOHU FAEs and product engineers sharing selection, cross-reference and troubleshooting know-how for communication components. About the team →
RELATED

Related articles

More on Common Mode Chokes, Ethernet PHY.

SUBSCRIBE

Subscribe to VOOHU technical articles

Get new articles in your inbox. Unsubscribe at any time.

By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy